The SPIVA U.S. Scorecard, published semi-annually by S&P Dow Jones Indices, tracks the performance of actively managed funds against their benchmarks over rolling time periods. The data is consistent, publicly available, and unambiguous: over any 10-year period, roughly 90 to 94 percent of large-cap active managers underperform the S&P 500.
This is not a controversial finding. It is not cherry-picked. It accounts for survivorship bias — the tendency of failed funds to quietly merge or close, disappearing from the record. When you include those ghost funds, the numbers get worse, not better. The question isn't whether most active managers underperform. The question is why so many investors continue to pay for active management despite the evidence.
Source: SPIVA® Scorecards, S&P Dow Jones Indices, published semi-annually and publicly available. Past performance of any manager or cohort does not predict future results. This is the opening of the argument, published as drafted — the full version arrives beforeBasis opens in Fall 2026.