Skip to content
Articles

What a decade of SPIVA data actually says about persistence

Among top-quartile managers, fewer than 3% maintained status over five consecutive years. Outperformance is non-repeating.

August 2026 · 1-minute read

The most common justification for paying active management fees is that a skilled manager will consistently outperform. The word "consistently" is doing all the work in that sentence. The S&P Persistence Scorecard tracks whether top-performing funds maintain their rankings over subsequent periods. The results are brutal: of funds that ranked in the top quartile over a given year, fewer than 3% remained in the top quartile for five consecutive years.

This isn't slightly below expectations — it's statistically indistinguishable from chance. If you randomly assigned performance rankings each year, you'd expect about 0.4% to stay in the top quartile for five straight years. The actual figure of roughly 3% barely clears that bar. Past performance, in other words, tells you almost nothing about future performance. This is not a caveat in the fine print. It is the central finding.

Source: S&P Persistence Scorecard, S&P Dow Jones Indices, published semi-annually and publicly available. Past performance of any manager or cohort does not predict future results. This is the opening of the argument, published as drafted — the full version arrives beforeBasis opens in Fall 2026.

Worth being plain about

  • This is an argument about how the industry is structured, not about any firm, adviser, or person working in it — and not about your situation, which it doesn't know.
  • Nothing here is investment, tax, or legal advice, an offer or solicitation, or a prediction — cited figures describe what large groups of funds already did, and past results do not predict future ones. Full disclosures are on the disclosures page.
  • Basis opens in Fall 2026 and takes no engagements before then.

Opening Fall 2026

Disagree with any of this?

Basis opens in Fall 2026 and takes no engagements before then. If you think one of these arguments is wrong — or it's the question you're actually sitting with — that's a conversation worth having. Say hello.

Work with usGet in touch.

Or write to hello@basis.cpa

Honolulu, Hawaii

Contact us

Basis opens in Fall 2026. Leave your name and email and we'll be in touch.


This opens your email app with the message ready to send.