The most common justification for paying active management fees is that a skilled manager will consistently outperform. The word "consistently" is doing all the work in that sentence. The S&P Persistence Scorecard tracks whether top-performing funds maintain their rankings over subsequent periods. The results are brutal: of funds that ranked in the top quartile over a given year, fewer than 3% remained in the top quartile for five consecutive years.
This isn't slightly below expectations — it's statistically indistinguishable from chance. If you randomly assigned performance rankings each year, you'd expect about 0.4% to stay in the top quartile for five straight years. The actual figure of roughly 3% barely clears that bar. Past performance, in other words, tells you almost nothing about future performance. This is not a caveat in the fine print. It is the central finding.
Source: S&P Persistence Scorecard, S&P Dow Jones Indices, published semi-annually and publicly available. Past performance of any manager or cohort does not predict future results. This is the opening of the argument, published as drafted — the full version arrives beforeBasis opens in Fall 2026.